RetireTheChief logo image A forum for discussion on retiring Chief Illiniwek
Welcome to RetireTheChief May 12, 2004 Vol. 3, No. 7
Home
Welcome
News
Letters
Resources
Dialogue
Archives
Chicago
Not a mascot
What honor?
Help
Contact
Search

click here
TEN REASONS TO RETIRE THE CHIEF
#7. Native Americans Aren't Honored
Instead, they Make Clear their Opposition to the Chief
May 15: Senate President Emil Jones has "Cordial" Meetings with Board of Trustees (News)

Native Americans
discuss Chief Illiniwek


Those in favor of retaining Chief Illiniwek as a UIUC symbol often point out their belief that the chief honors Native Americans. However sincere the intent, recent protests show that Native Americans do not feel honored by the Chief. Rather, many find it offends them at a very personal, even spiritual, level.

Earlier this year, several members of the Native American community in Chicago agreed to be interviewed, and to describe their feelings about Chief Illiniwek. Included were the president of Chicago's NAES College and the director of the American Indian Center. Excerpts from these interviews appear below, along with links to movies in which they say how they feel about the Chief. Click on any image for a movie, or choose a movie (or audio-only MP3) link below the image.


Faith Smith
President, NAES College, Chicago


QT movie (4 MB), Audio only (MP3; 2 MB)

Faith Smith is President of the Native American Educational Services (NAES) College in Chicago. NAES College is the only independent, Native owned and controlled college in the United States, and has had a degree program for 30 years.

"Why is it that institutions in our society cannot deal with us as Native people in the present - so we're Native people in the past ... and so it becomes harmful."

"When you see something like a Chief Illiniwek, where a symbol has become so outrageous - it's not that it is a little off, it's totally outrageous."

"I can't find any way that anybody at the University would think that keeping this symbol in any way honors Native people."


Joe Podlasek
Director, American Indian Center


QT movie (1 MB), Audio only (MP3; 500 KB)

Joe Podlasek is Executive Director of the American Indian Center (AIC) in Chicago, which is the oldest urban American Indian center in the United States. AIC was founded in 1953, and Mr. Podlasek has served as director since 2001.

"People need to take the time to learn about who American Indians really are ... and understand and respect the issues that are at hand. By doing that, I think it will be a clearer decision to remove the Chief."


Leonard Malatare
NAES College, Chicago


QT movie (3 MB), Audio only (MP3; 1 MB)

"[the Chief] creates a hostile environment for the American Indian to have to live in."

"We moved out to the suburbs ... we moved into a hostile environment ... My son soon felt like he was being discriminated against. His peers used to holler at him: 'Hey squaw, do a rain dance for us.'"

"This is the type of thing that is going on all over Indian America ... this is happening to Indian children all over the United States in urban areas. Everybody has misconceptions about Native Americans, and stereotypes, racist images, mascots, professional team names -- all of this adds to the racism that is going on against the American Indian today. It needs to stop. It needs to stop now."

"While you sit at your half-time shows and have fun, it is hurting a race of people. It is hurting the American Indian."

Yvonne Casanova
Executive Director, Coalition
of the Chicago Indian Community


QT movie (3 MB), Audio only (MP3; 1 MB)

Yvonne Casanova is an attorney and Director of the Coalition of the Chicago American Indian Community. The Coalition addresses issues affecting Chicago and statewide American Indians.

"We view [the Chief] as not authentic and not particularly flattering ... for most Indian people, we've had to live with stereotypes. For the most part, the stereotypes have not been easy to live with... I've been asked if we still live in tents."

"The Chief portraying Indians as half-time entertainment doesn't sit well with most Native people; I know it doesn't sit well with me."


Davis Wounded Eye


QT movie (4 MB), Audio only (MP3; 1 MB)

"I was taught to respect people, I was taught to respect myself, our ways of life ... I believe that Chief Illiniwek is a disgrace to our people, and he has no significance that is honorable to us as Indian people."

"The feathers that [the Chief] wears are sacred to our people ... it is not to be played with, or made fun of."

"It's not up to the students either, because the students are only going to be there for four years, and they're going to move on ... My son is Native American, and he's going to be Native American his whole life."


Christine Redcloud
American Indian Center, Chicago


QT movie (600 KB), Audio only (MP3; 200 KB)

Christine Redcloud is a Board Member of the Chicago American Indian Center, and serves as Faculty Chair, Academic Advisor and Registrar at NAES College.

"If they don't retire the Chief, it's going to be the same controvery 20 years from now, when [her son] is looking for a school to go to."

"We've said it all before. How many times do we have to say it? How many different ways can we say it?"


SD High School Students
Sign anti-Chief Petition

On April 15-16, over 240 students and teachers at Pine Ridge(SD) High School signed a petition calling for retirement of the Chief. The petition and signatures were sent to Governor Blagojevich and to the U. of I.  

Click to see petition & signatures


Remember?      March 15, 2004      Native Americans protest at the University of Illinois

Ten Reasons to Retire The Chief
  • 1. Diversity. We do want a diverse, inclusive atmosphere welcoming of all cultures.
  • 2. Stereotypes. The Chief perpetuates harmful, insulting stereotypes of Native people in a big way.
  • 3. Publicity. The presence of the Chief has brought national disapproval to an outstanding University.
  • 4. Racism. It was not the intention, and no one likes the "R" word, but Native Americans are very upset by the presence of Chief Illiniwek.
  • 5. Children. Powerful stereotypes are particularly harmful to children - their self esteem and school performance.
  • 6. Accuracy. Let's be honest - the Chief isn't the real thing. The dance is part of half-time entertainment.
  • 7. Honor. Native Americans are not honored. Quite the contrary, they have made it clear they are quite offended.
  • 8. NCAA. In case you missed it, the NCAA has made it clear they are unhappy with American Indian mascots.
  • 9. Choices. Potential faculty and students have chosen not to teach or attend the University because of the Chief.
  • 10. Image. Call the Chief a symbol or a mascot - he is a public figure that harms the University's image.


WELCOME This site exists to give a voice to those who believe Chief Illiniwek should be retired, to promote discussion between those who are pro- and anti-Chief, and to encourage a change in policy - to retire the Chief. We want to turn up the volume on the Chief debate. Regardless of your stand on this divisive issue, welcome .